Home » Blog » Stone Flooring: Should You Replace or Refinish

When choosing the best flooring option for your home, the stone is timeless for its durability and exceptional aesthetic. However, as with any flooring material, you need regular maintenance over time. Should you need to replace or refinish stone floors in your home, deciding between these two options requires some knowledge of their respective installation and refurbishment processes. In this post, we’ll discuss the pros and cons of replacing versus refinishing stone flooring so you can decide what’s best for your specific needs.

What is Stone Flooring?

Stone flooring is one of the oldest types found in architecture and is still widely used today. It provides a timeless sense of beauty and elegance like no other material can while providing durable and long-lasting performance. With a range of different types, such as marble, granite, slate, limestone, or travertine stone flooring can easily accommodate many different styles and design concepts. With good maintenance and care, these floors can last for decades. When considering stone flooring for any project, it is essential to understand the characteristics of each type to ensure that you are making the right choice for your needs.

Benefits of Stone Flooring

Stone flooring offers many benefits in both home and commercial settings. It is naturally strong, durable, and resistant to stains and fading. Additionally, the stone is environment-friendly as it is made of natural materials. Regular maintenance and care make it easy to retain its luster for years. Furthermore, stone flooring also has insulation properties, helping maintain warmth in the winter while being cool in the summer. Finally, it has a timeless appeal that can easily match different furniture styles and wall color schemes. All these qualities make stone flooring an excellent long-term investment for any home or business space.

How to Refinish or Replace Stone Flooring

Stone flooring can instantly upgrade the look and feel of a home, but it can require upkeep to maintain its aesthetic. Replacing or refinishing stone flooring can be quite a task, but if done correctly, it can help retain natural stone’s incredible characteristics for years. For stone refinishing or slate tile repairs in Chicago, it’s best to hire professionals. If a homeowner has existing stone flooring that requires refinishing, then he/she should take detailed measurements of the affected area(s) and purchase the same type of rock from a reliable supplier. Once this is done, replacing or refinishing the stone should be a relatively straightforward job, with only minor details needing attention to produce satisfactory results. Alternatively, if more space is desired or unforeseen issues arise while refinishing bathroom tile or kitchen countertops, experienced professionals can provide valuable insight into the process.

Key Factors You Should Consider Before Replace or Refinish the Stone Flooring

Scratches and Dents

Before deciding on whether to replace or refinish your stone flooring, the extent of damages, such as scratches and dents, should first be assessed. Scratches can be polished out, but deeper scratches may require complete grinding and refinishing. On the other hand, dents cannot be repaired with refinishing but instead need replacing the damaged tile. It is essential to take note of the type of stone flooring you have, as some varieties are more susceptible to scratches and dents than others.


Efflorescence is a common problem in stone flooring, where white spots or haze appear on the surface due to the buildup of mineral salts. While efflorescence can be removed through cleaning or refinishing, it is essential to first address the underlying issue causing the buildup, such as excessive moisture or poor installation. Ignoring the underlying problem can result in the efflorescence appearing again in the future. Before deciding whether to replace or refinish your stone flooring affected by efflorescence, consult a professional to ensure the problem is fully resolved.

Financial Factors

Replacing or refinishing stone flooring can be a significant investment. Before deciding, consider the cost of each option and compare it to your budget. If you opt for refinishing, factor in the age and condition of your current flooring. Refinishing can be less expensive than replacing, but if the floor is too damaged, refinishing may only be a temporary solution. Additionally, consider the cost of labor and any necessary repairs that may arise during the process. Lastly, research any financing options that could make the project more manageable.

Grout Issue and New Cracks

Stone flooring is durable, but the grout between tiles may crack over time, and the flooring may develop new cracks. These issues can weaken the floor and make it more susceptible to damage. Before replacing or refinishing, assess the severity of any grout or crack matters. Minor cracks and grout problems can easily be fixed with sealant or grout, but more severe cracks may require replacement. Always consult with a professional to determine the best course of action. Ignoring these issues can lead to more expensive problems down the road.

Squeaking or Creaking

If you notice your stone flooring making a squeaking or creaking sound, it indicates there are issues with your subfloor or flooring system. Before replacing or refinishing your stone flooring, it is essential to identify the root cause of the problem. Some common causes of squeaky or creaky stone floors include subfloor movement, moisture damage, or wear and tear of the flooring system. In most cases, the subfloor must be examined and fixed before any further action. Hiring a professional to assess and fix the problem is recommended for the best outcome.

Final Words

In conclusion, the decision between replacing and refinishing the stone floor should come down to the needs and desires of each individual. If cost is a priority, then refinishing may be the best option, as replacing will cost far less. You can get quotes for limestone tile restoration in Chicago from experts. However, suppose there are certain flaws and wear or significant damage that cannot be addressed through refinishing. In that case, replacement may be the only choice. Moreover, private preferences between glossy or matte finishes should also factor into this decision. Ultimately, you should seek advice from experienced professionals to determine what type of stone flooring is most suitable for your space and style of living before taking action. Say goodbye to boring stone floors today and make a lasting statement with stylish replacements or refined finishes!

Author icon

About the author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *